Does My Lab Feel Guilt When I Correct Them?

Jane Davis

Note: If you click a link on this page, then go on to make a purchase, we may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you

When you correct your Labrador for a misdeed, you might notice a distinct change in their behavior. They may lower their head, avoid eye contact, or tuck their tail between their legs.

It’s a common belief that these behaviors indicate that your dog feels guilty for their actions.

However, it’s essential to understand that dogs live in the moment, and their understanding of cause and effect is grounded in immediate consequences.

The look that appears to be ‘guilt’ is your dog’s reaction to your body language and tone of voice.

While they may not comprehend the exact nature of their fault according to human standards, they are incredibly adept at reading our signals and responding submissively, which might be mistaken for guilt.

An essential aspect of training is realizing that dogs, including Labradors, associate actions with consequences very quickly. For a lesson to be learned, any correction should happen immediately after the misdeed.

If you scold your Lab minutes after doing something wrong, they won’t connect the scolding to the action.

They react to how you behave in the present, not to the past actions they’ve taken.

Understanding Canine Emotions

When you observe your Labrador’s behavior, it’s natural to wonder if they experience emotions similar to ours, such as guilt. Let’s explore what is known about your dog’s emotional experiences.

Defining Guilt in Dogs

As humans experience it, guilt involves a complex understanding of moral codes and reflecting on past actions, something beyond what dogs are believed to possess.

Your Labrador may show signs that look like guilt—such as averting gaze, tucking their tail, or hiding—but these are likely responses to your immediate behavior or emotions rather than an internal feeling of guilt about a past action.

Canine Cognition and Emotions

It’s now understood that dogs have a range of emotions, but they differ in complexity compared to humans. Your dog’s emotions are more immediate and not tied to complex reflections on past behaviors.

When correcting your dog, remember that dogs live in the moment and quickly connect their actions to consequences.

Positive reinforcement is, therefore, considered the most effective training method, as it aligns with how dogs process the world around them.

Interpreting Dog Behavior

Man tells his labrador that it did something wrong. Outside in the woods

When correcting your Labrador, understanding their responses is crucial for practical training. Misinterpreting your dog’s reactions can lead to communication barriers and hinder progress.

Common Misinterpretations

Misinterpreting submissive behaviors as guilt is a standard error. Expressions that convey guilt, such as averted gazes or lowered heads, are often misconstrued.

These behaviors are typically your Lab’s way of showing submission or confusion rather than an indicator of remorse for a past action.

Signs of Stress vs. Guilt

It’s essential to distinguish between signs of stress and the mythical concept of guilt in dogs. Stress indicators include:

  • Pacing
  • Whining
  • Excessive grooming

Conversely, canine behavior experts do not substantiate what is often thought to be guilt, such as avoiding eye contact or slinking away.

Dogs live in the moment and do not connect past actions with current reactions beyond immediate consequences.

Correcting Your Lab: Best Practices

When training and correcting your Labrador, understanding their perspective is crucial.

Tailor your approach to their learning process, focus on constructive interactions, and establish clear expectations.

Positive Reinforcement

Employ positive reinforcement to encourage your Lab to repeat desirable behaviors. This could include:

  • Treats: Give a small treat immediately after your Lab performs the right action.
  • Praise: Use a happy, enthusiastic voice to approve good behavior.
  • Petting: Offer physical affection as a reward for following commands correctly.
Sitting on commandTreat and verbal praiseEncourages obedience and calmness

Effective Communication

Communicate effectively to prevent confusion and understand your Lab’s perspective. Keep these points in mind:

  • Clear Commands: Use short, distinct words to indicate expected actions.
  • Consistent Signals: Choose hand signals or verbal cues and use them consistently.
  • Immediate Response: React immediately to your Lab’s behavior to maintain a clear association between the behavior and your correction or praise.

Setting Boundaries

Clearly define and consistently enforce rules to maintain a structure for your Lab. Be specific about boundaries for:

  • Spaces: Designate places in the house where your Lab is allowed or not allowed.
  • Behavior: Delineate acceptable and unacceptable behaviors, such as jumping on guests or barking.

Remember to stay calm and composed when enforcing these rules to avoid causing stress or confusion in your Lab.


Jane Davis

Hi, my name is Jane Davis, and I love dogs. I own a labrador retriever named Max. When I was growing up, we always had dogs at our house. They provide us with such unconditional love and companionship, and I can't imagine my life without one by my side.

This website does not provide pet medical advice. For professional advice regarding your pet's health, please consult a licensed veterinarian in your local area.