Labs vs. Other Dog Breeds

Labrador Retriever vs. Collie

Jane Davis

Note: If you click a link on this page, then go on to make a purchase, we may receive a commission but at no extra cost to you

Hello there! Today, I’d like to introduce you to two amazing dog breeds that I’ve had the pleasure of knowing extensively: the Labrador Retriever and the Collie.

Both breeds are incredible companions and have their unique set of features and qualities that make them popular choices for families seeking furry friends.

Labrador Retriever

The Labrador is America’s sweetheart and for good reason. With their sweet faces and lovable nature, they are the epitome of friendliness.

Labradors are medium-to-large dogs, standing between 21.5 to 24.5 inches and weighing from 55 to 80 pounds. Their dense, hard coat comes in yellow, black, or chocolate, and that adorable ‘otter tail’ is ever-wagging, reflecting their boundless enthusiasm.

read.. Discover everything there is to know about Labrador Retrievers

Labradors are renowned for their friendly and sociable nature, making them wonderful companions for the whole family. They are full of energy, requiring ample exercise to stay physically and mentally fit.


The majestic Collie is a pop-culture star, and you can easily see why. This large yet lithe herding breed stands between 22 to 26 inches tall and weighs from 50 to 75 pounds.

With two varieties – rough and smooth coats – Collies are truly a sight to behold. Their coat colors range from sable and white to tricolor and blue merle.

Collies are known for their elegant wedge-shaped heads, captivating almond eyes, and expressive ears.

They are especially fond of children and make fantastic family pets. These agile dogs thrive on companionship and regular exercise, and their intelligence makes training a breeze.


Comparison Table

FeatureLabrador RetrieverCollie
Size & WeightMedium-to-large dog, 21.5 to 24.5 inches, 55-80 lbsLarge dog, 22 to 26 inches, 50-75 lbs
Coat Types & ColorsDense, hard coat, yellow, black, chocolateFull-coated ‘rough’ or sleek ‘smooth,’ various colors
TemperamentFriendly, outgoing, affectionateAffectionate, gentle, devoted, protective
Work Ethic & IntelligenceExcellent work ethic, ideal for service tasksBrilliant herding instinct, excels in dog sports
Family Pet & AffectionGreat family pet, friendly with childrenExcellent family companion, fond of kids
Loyalty & CourageLoyal, not strongly protectiveLoyal, naturally protective and vigilant
TrainabilityQuick learners, eager to pleaseEager learners, gentle training works well
Exercise NeedsHigh energy, requires regular exerciseAgile and active, needs regular exercise
Lifespan10-12 years12-14 years

Work Ethic & Intelligence

Both Labradors and Collies excel in their work ethic, but they tend to have different focuses due to their respective histories.

Labradors were originally bred as retrievers for hunters, and their intelligence and strong work ethic make them exceptional assistance dogs, search and rescue dogs, and guide dogs.

They take well to training and are quick learners, allowing them to perform various tasks with precision and dedication.

On the other hand, Collies have a rich herding heritage, and their intelligence and agility have made them fantastic herding dogs.

They have an innate ability to gather and control livestock, making them invaluable on farms.

Additionally, their intelligence and trainability have made them adept at various dog sports and obedience competitions.

Expert Opinion: Both breeds are highly intelligent and excel in their respective fields of work. The Labrador’s focus on assistance and service tasks makes them ideal for people who need support or require a working companion.

Collies are the perfect choice for individuals who live on farms or enjoy participating in dog sports that showcase the breed’s herding abilities.

Family Pet & Affection

When it comes to being a family pet, both Labradors and Collies are top-notch choices. Labradors are famously friendly and outgoing, making them wonderful with children and other pets.

They form strong bonds with their families and are always eager to shower them with affection. Their playful and gentle nature ensures they can be trusted around kids, and their high energy levels mean they can keep up with an active household.

Collies, too, are exceptional family pets. Their loving and devoted nature means they thrive in a family environment, where they can be an integral part of the household.

They are famously fond of children and can be incredibly gentle and patient, making them perfect companions for kids of all ages.

Expert Opinion: Both breeds are known for their affectionate and gentle nature, making them excellent choices for families.

If you have small children, the Labrador’s playful and sturdy demeanor might be more suitable, as they can withstand rough play better than the more delicate Collie.

Loyalty & Courage

When it comes to loyalty, both Labradors and Collies are fiercely devoted to their owners. They form strong bonds and will go to great lengths to protect and care for their human family members.

Labradors’ friendly nature extends to everyone, which means they may not be the most protective of watchdogs, but their loyalty to their family remains unwavering.

Collies are naturally protective of their family and can exhibit a sense of guardianship.

Their loyalty and courage make them excellent watchdogs, always keeping a vigilant eye on their surroundings and ready to alert their owners to anything amiss.

Expert Opinion: Both breeds are loyal and courageous, but if you are looking for a dog with a more protective instinct, the Collie might be the better choice.

Their natural guarding tendencies and vigilance make them excellent at safeguarding their family and property.


In conclusion, both the Labrador Retriever and the Collie are exceptional breeds with their unique strengths and qualities.

Labradors’ friendly and outgoing nature, combined with their intelligence and work ethic, make them fantastic assistance and service dogs, as well as beloved family pets.

Collies, with their regal appearance, herding heritage, and loyalty, excel as herding dogs and are devoted and loving family companions.

The choice between these two wonderful breeds ultimately depends on your lifestyle, preferences, and specific needs.

If you seek a playful, outgoing, and adaptable companion who can excel in various tasks, the Labrador might be your ideal match.

On the other hand, if you desire a loyal, protective, and elegant dog with a herding background, the Collie could be the perfect fit.

Remember to consider factors like exercise requirements, grooming needs, and space available for your furry friend to thrive.

Whichever breed you choose, you can’t go wrong with the love, joy, and companionship they will bring into your life.


Jane Davis

Hi, my name is Jane Davis, and I love dogs. I own a labrador retriever named Max. When I was growing up, we always had dogs at our house. They provide us with such unconditional love and companionship, and I can't imagine my life without one by my side.

This website does not provide pet medical advice. For professional advice regarding your pet's health, please consult a licensed veterinarian in your local area.